What is the scariest horror movie of all time? Science of Scare reveals its 2026 ranking

Cinema. (Illustrative photo)

The 2012 horror film Sinister has retained its title as the scariest movie in the latest Science of Scare ranking, while the 2026 release Resident Evil has set a new record for the biggest jump scare ever recorded by the project.

On 09/11/2026 at 21h00

Directed by Scott Derrickson and starring Ethan Hawke, Sinister topped the 2026 ranking with a score of 96 out of 100. The film has held the top position for four consecutive years.

The annual project, now in its seventh year, measures viewers’ physical reactions while they watch horror films. This year’s experiment involved 250 volunteers fitted with heart rate monitors during screenings of English-language titles.

Sinister raised the panel’s average heart rate by 34%, from 64 to 86 beats per minute (BPM). Its most frightening scene pushed the rate to 131 BPM, while viewers’ heart rate variability dropped by 21%, indicating a strong stress response.

Resident Evil breaks jump-scare record

Although it did not make the overall top 50, Zach Cregger’s Resident Evil recorded the highest heart rate peak in the project’s history.

The film pushed one viewer’s heart rate to 134 BPM, a 70 BPM increase that broke the previous record of 133 BPM held by Insidious since the project’s first study in 2020.

The result made Resident Evil the most effective film at producing a sudden physical reaction, but it was not enough to secure a high overall ranking. The film placed 56th, with its shift towards darkly comic action in the second half giving viewers time to recover from the initial shocks.

Another 2026 release, A24’s Undertone, was ranked the scariest newcomer. It tied for 33rd place with a score of 63, largely because of its effect on viewers’ heart rate variability. The film recorded a 22% drop, matching Skinamarink for the largest decrease ever measured by the project.

The 10 highest-ranked horror films

The ranking combines three measurements: average heart rate during a film, changes in heart rate variability and the highest heart rate reached during its most intense moments.

Sinister led the list with 96 points, followed closely by Rob Savage’s Host with 95 and Skinamarink with 91.

The rest of the top 10 included Insidious (90), The Conjuring (88), Hereditary (81), Smile 2 (79), Smile (78), The Exorcism of Emily Rose (76), and Talk to Me and Hell House LLC, which tied for 10th place with 75 points each.

The Science of Scare project first began in 2020. Its organizers say the scoring system was expanded in 2023 to include heart rate variability, in an effort to account for the tension and lingering dread that do not always produce sudden jumps in heart rate.

The results are published annually ahead of Halloween by MoneySuperMarket, which organizes the experiment.

By Hind Braim
On 09/11/2026 at 21h00